Private Mortgages Canada
Back to Home
Resources Insights Contact Us

Private Mortgage Exit Strategy: The Complete Guide for Canadian Borrowers

Streetwise Mortgages
•
•
17 min read

A private mortgage exit strategy is your written plan for paying off a private mortgage before its term ends, usually by refinancing with a bank or B-lender, or by selling. Private mortgages are built to be short, typically 6 to 24 months, and they cost more than bank loans. Without a plan, it is easy to reach the end of the term not ready to refinance and have to renew, paying a new round of fees each time. At Private Mortgages Canada, every deal we structure includes an exit plan, because a private mortgage without one is not a bridge, it is a dead end. The best private mortgage brokerages in Ontario design the exit before they fund the loan, and it is increasingly a regulatory priority for FSRA, the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario. We don't just approve the loan. We approve the exit.

This guide covers what a good exit plan includes, two worked examples, realistic timelines, and what to do if things slip.

Why the Plan Matters

Private mortgage rates in Ontario range from 7% to 14%, compared with 4% to 6% for bank mortgages. Each renewal of a private mortgage typically adds 1% to 3% in lender fees and 1% to 2% in broker fees on top of the interest, so on a $500,000 loan an unplanned renewal could add $10,000 to $25,000 in costs.

Regulators expect a plan too. FSRA's 2025-2026 supervision plan explicitly prioritizes exit strategy documentation in private mortgage transactions, and FSRA expects brokers to assess and document the borrower's ability to repay or refinance at maturity. In over 6,500 deals funded across the Streetwise platform, we have seen that the difference between borrowers who move on to a bank and those who don't is almost always the quality of the exit plan built at the start.

The cost of running late

Take a $500,000 private mortgage at 10%. If you are not ready to refinance when the 12-month term ends and you need six more months, a renewal could look like this:

Six more months of interest at 10%$25,000
Renewal fee (1% of the balance)$5,000
Legal costs for the renewal (approx.)$1,500
Extra cost of being six months lateAbout $31,500

If the same loan had moved to a bank at 5%, those six months would have cost about $12,500 in interest. The difference, roughly $19,000, is what a weak plan costs, and it grows with every further renewal. Use the APR calculator to run your own numbers.

The Five Things a Good Exit Plan Covers

Each part has a clear target, so you and your broker can tell whether you are on track.

1. Credit

Credit is the most common reason people can't refinance on time. Many B-lenders look for a score of about 600 to 650 (target 620 or more), and banks usually want 680 or higher. Starting below 550, that typically takes 12 to 18 months of disciplined effort; starting at 580 to 620, 6 to 12 months is often enough. A borrower starting at 520 needs more time than one at 590. Most private lenders don't report to the credit bureaus, so your mortgage payments won't build your score. That has to come from your other accounts:

  • Pay every bill on time. Payment history makes up about 35% of a credit score. Set up automatic payments.
  • Keep credit card balances under 30% of the limit (below $3,000 on a $10,000 limit), and under 10% if you can.
  • Keep old accounts open and avoid applying for new credit.
  • Get your reports from Equifax and TransUnion and dispute any errors.
  • If your file is thin, a secured credit card can help rebuild it.

2. Proof of income

Banks and B-lenders want income on paper: pay slips, tax returns and notices of assessment. File any late tax returns right away, because missing returns stop a refinance cold. If you are self-employed, talk to your accountant early about whether to claim fewer deductions so your reported income qualifies. Most lenders want two years of returns.

3. The property's value

The new lender will lend a share of the appraised value. Aim for a loan of 80% of value or less for a conventional refinance, or 75% for the best rates. Finishing planned renovations, fixing obvious repairs before the appraisal and, for rentals, getting tenants in with signed leases all help the property appraise well.

4. Other debts

Banks limit how much of your income can go to housing costs (GDS, usually a maximum of 32% to 39%) and to all your debts combined (TDS, usually 42% to 44%). Aim for GDS below 39% and TDS below 44% on your documented income and the projected new payment. Paying down credit cards, lines of credit and car loans, and not taking on new debt, makes those numbers work. Under OSFI guidelines, you must also qualify at the higher of your contract rate plus 2% or the 5.25% benchmark rate, so you need room above the actual payment.

5. Timing the application

Start the refinance about 90 days before the private term ends. Order an updated appraisal, gather your documents, and aim to have the application in at least 60 days before maturity so there is time to deal with any conditions the new lender sets. At PMC, we coordinate this step directly. With the Bank of Canada having reduced rates through 2025, the bank rate landscape in 2026 may be more favourable for refinancing. According to CMHC, approximately $315 billion in Canadian mortgages were scheduled for renewal in 2025-2026.

Two Worked Examples

These are illustrations, not real clients.

A business owner with big write-offs: 12 months

A business owner brings in $250,000 a year but reports $85,000 after deductions, so the bank declines a refinance. They take a 12-month private mortgage. The plan:

  • Months 1 to 2: meet the accountant and agree to report more income on the coming tax return; confirm credit is already above 680.
  • Months 3 to 6: file the return showing the higher income; keep business and personal banking separate.
  • Months 7 to 9: receive the notice of assessment; the broker confirms the income now fits a B-lender's limits.
  • Months 9 to 12: updated appraisal, application in, private mortgage paid off before the term ends.

See self-employed mortgages for more on this situation.

A homeowner after a power of sale scare: 24 months

A homeowner fell behind after a job loss and received a notice of sale. Their credit score dropped to 540. A private mortgage pays the arrears and stops the sale. They are working again, but they need time. The plan:

  • Months 1 to 6: every bill on autopay, a secured credit card, card balances paid down, errors disputed.
  • Months 7 to 12: score climbing; the first full year of new employment income on record; review the plan and renew the private term if needed, as planned from the start.
  • Months 13 to 18: score in the 620s; debts lower; documents gathered.
  • Months 19 to 24: refinance with a B-lender, then aim for a bank at the next renewal.

If a plan needs 24 months, saying so up front is better than pretending it will take 12. For this situation, see stopping a power of sale.

How Long Does It Take?

Most successful exits happen within 12 to 24 months. These two framework timelines are based on the approach we use across our 6,500+ deal track record.

The 12-month timeline

For borrowers close to qualifying: credit score above 580, established income documents, and a property that needs little work.

MonthMilestoneActions
1-2BaselineCredit report review, income document check, appraisal, gap analysis
3-4Active workStart credit repair, file any outstanding tax returns, start property improvements
5-6Mid-term checkUpdated credit score, document progress, adjust timeline if needed
7-8PreparationBuild the bank application package, engage the broker, order an updated appraisal
9-10Pre-qualificationPreliminary application to the target lender, deal with any gaps
11-12RefinanceFinal approval, legal work, private mortgage paid off

The 24-month timeline

For borrowers who need more time: credit scores below 550, limited income documents, or properties needing major renovation.

MonthMilestoneActions
1-3FoundationCredit review and disputes, file outstanding returns, start stabilising the property
4-6Early progressSteady payment history, first year of income documents, finish renovations
7-9MomentumScore trending up, second year of documents underway, property stabilised
10-12Year one reviewFull review of credit, income and property value; adjust the plan
13-15Second yearScore near target, second year of returns being prepared, debts falling
16-18Pre-applicationFull document package, engage the broker, confirm every criterion
19-21ApplicationSubmit, meet lender conditions, final appraisal
22-24RefinanceApproval, legal work, private mortgage paid off

Both timelines assume active participation and regular check-ins. At PMC, we schedule quarterly reviews with borrowers to track progress against the plan and adjust as circumstances change. Many people move in two steps: private to a B-lender, then B-lender to a bank.

A Good Plan vs a Weak One

A weak plan is one line that says "refinance at maturity." A good plan is:

  • Specific: it names the kind of lender you are aiming for and what that lender needs.
  • Measurable: it sets targets, such as a credit score of 650 by month 9, a GDS ratio below 35% by month 12, and a loan of 78% of projected value.
  • Honest: it starts from where you are today, not where you wish you were.
  • Checked: progress is reviewed quarterly at minimum so problems are caught early.
  • The lender's concern too: at PMC, exit viability is part of the underwriting decision. If the exit does not work on paper, we do not approve the deal.

If the Plan Slips

  • The property appraises low: pay down some of the loan if your terms allow it, ask for an extension, or aim for a B-lender that lends a higher share of value.
  • Tax returns are late: start with your accountant in month one and build two or three months of buffer into the plan.
  • A surprise hits your credit: deal with it straight away by disputing errors and talking to the creditor. A few months of buffer absorbs most setbacks.
  • Rates rise: higher rates make the stress test harder to pass. Pay down other debts to keep your numbers in range. Note that switching to a variable-rate mortgage will not avoid the stress test: under OSFI's current rules, fixed and variable uninsured mortgages are stress-tested the same way.

This is why quarterly reviews are essential: the earlier a problem is spotted, the more options there are.

How PMC Builds Your Exit

Private Mortgages Canada was founded on a principle set out by Dalia Barsoum, 2x Mortgage Broker of the Year, CMP Global Top Broker and best-selling author of Canadian Real Estate Investor Financing: the most important part of a private mortgage is the plan to get out of it.

  • Before funding: we assess your finances, property and goals, identify the exit path and stress-test it against falling values, slower paperwork and rate changes. If the exit is not viable under reasonable stress scenarios, we will not fund the deal.
  • At origination: every PMC deal includes a documented exit strategy with milestones, timelines and action items, delivered as part of your mortgage documents.
  • During the term: regular reviews track credit, income documents and local market conditions, and we adjust early when needed.
  • At exit: we coordinate directly with the new lender so the move is seamless.

Across 6,500+ deals and $2B+ in capital deployed over 20+ years, this approach has been refined through every market condition Ontario has experienced.

What Ontario Rules Mean for You

Ontario has the largest private mortgage market in Canada. Anyone who arranges a private mortgage must be licensed by FSRA under the Mortgage Brokerages, Lenders and Administrators Act (MBLAA) and must give you every cost in writing. Brokers have a duty to ensure the mortgage is suitable for you, and FSRA's supervisory framework expects them to assess and document how you will repay or refinance at maturity. FSRA's 2025-2026 supervision plan explicitly identifies exit strategy assessment as a priority area for compliance reviews. At PMC, we go beyond the regulatory minimum: if we cannot identify a viable exit, we will not fund the loan. In practice, any licensed broker should be able to answer four questions before your loan funds:

  • How will I repay or refinance this loan when the term ends?
  • Is that realistic from where I am today?
  • What has to happen, and by when?
  • What is the backup if it doesn't?

When choosing a brokerage, also ask whether it will decline a deal with no viable exit, whether it monitors the plan during the term, and what its track record is. A brokerage that has structured thousands of deals has pattern recognition that newer operators lack. You can check any broker's licence on FSRA's public register. For a full picture of costs, see the true cost of a private mortgage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a private mortgage exit strategy?

It is a written plan for paying off a private mortgage before the term ends, usually by refinancing with a bank or B-lender or by selling. It sets targets for credit, income documents, the property's value and your other debts, along with a timeline.

How long does it take to move from a private mortgage to a bank?

Usually 12 to 24 months. People who are close to qualifying (credit above 580, established income documents) can often do it in about a year. Those who need to rebuild credit and income history may need two years, sometimes with a B-lender in between.

What credit score do I need to refinance out of a private mortgage?

Many B-lenders look for about 600 to 650. Banks usually want 680 or more. Your plan should set the target for the lender you are aiming for.

Does a private mortgage help my credit?

Usually not directly, because most private lenders don't report to the credit bureaus. Your score improves through on-time payments and lower balances on your other accounts.

Does FSRA require exit strategies?

FSRA expects mortgage brokers in Ontario to assess and document the borrower's ability to repay or refinance at maturity, and its 2025-2026 supervision plan explicitly identifies exit strategy assessment as a priority area for private mortgage transactions.

What is exit-first lending?

It is the principle that a private mortgage should only be funded if a viable exit has been identified and documented before closing. At PMC, if no viable exit exists, we will not fund the deal.

What if I can't refinance before the term ends?

You would need to renew, if the lender agrees, which means more interest plus a renewal fee and legal costs. A good plan builds in a buffer and a backup, and starts the refinance about 90 days before the term ends.

Start With the Way Out

Whether you are thinking about a private mortgage or already have one and need a clearer path, send us your deal snapshot or call 1-800-208-6255. We will look at where you are, map the exit, and tell you honestly whether private money is the right bridge. Our approach is informed by 20+ years of experience and $2B+ in capital deployed.

Private Mortgages Canada is a division of Streetwise Mortgages (trade name of Real Estate Wealth Builders Inc.), licensed by the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA). Dalia Barsoum, founder, is a 2x Mortgage Broker of the Year, CMP Global Top Broker, and best-selling author of Canadian Real Estate Investor Financing. PMC is a mortgage brokerage and does not lend its own funds. Examples are illustrations, and rates, fees and terms vary by deal. This guide is general information, not financial, legal or tax advice.

Ready to Explore Your Options?

Our specialists can help you understand how private mortgage solutions apply to your specific situation.